.

Top 5 Shopify Membership Apps to Grow Customer Loyalty

8 min read · 18 minutes ago
Top 5 Shopify Membership Apps

Picture two shoppers on your Shopify store. Both love your coffee beans. One buys a bag whenever she remembers, which is maybe twice a year. The other pays a few dollars a month for free shipping and member pricing. She orders every two weeks without a reminder.

The product is the same, and the price gap is tiny. Yet one customer drifts away while the other keeps coming back. If you have paid for ads only to watch first-time buyers vanish, this gap feels personal. The coffee did not change. A small, paid commitment turned a casual buyer into a regular.

A membership program changes that pattern. In a McKinsey survey, paid loyalty members were 60% more likely to spend more after joining, versus 30% for free programs. Here are five Shopify membership apps that help, followed by the what, why, where, and when.

Key Takeaways

  • Membership apps turn one-time buyers into paying members with recurring billing and automatic perks.
  • Paid members return because they want value from the fee they already paid.
  • Match the pricing model (flat tiers, per-member, transaction, or usage bands) to your expected member count.
  • Simple perks, failed-payment retries, and easy cancellation keep members longer.

Shopify Membership Apps at a Glance

AppDeveloperBilling modelFree entry pointStandout strength
Appstle MembershipsAppstle MembershipsFlat monthly tiers by member count; no per-member feesFree plan, up to 25 membershipsAll-in-one plans, perks, billing, plus dunning
Simplee Memberships & LoyaltySimplee Memberships & Loyalty$9.75/month base plus a per-active-member fee that drops as you growFree on development storesMember discounts at Shopify POS and store credit on membership orders
Conjured MembershipsConjuredMonthly fee plus a % of membership transactions that drops on higher plans30-day free trial on paid plansGated classes, downloads, and fully customizable HTML
Bold Memberships & LoyaltyBold$0.13 per member per month, no base feeFirst 10 members free foreverWallet member cards at POS and multi-brand programs
Zendra MembershipsKestrelFree plan, then $9/month plus usage bandsFree plan, up to 75 membersDrip access, Discord roles, 36 languages

What Would 100 Members Cost You?

An illustrative estimate from each listing’s published pricing, assuming 100 active members paying $10 per month each.

AppPlan used for estimateEstimated monthly app cost
Appstle MembershipsStarter (up to 100 memberships)$19
Simplee Memberships & LoyaltyGrowth: $9.75 + $0.05 to $0.30 per active memberAbout $14.75 to $39.75
Conjured MembershipsStarter: $19 + 1.9% of $1,000 membership revenueAbout $38
Bold Memberships & LoyaltyScale: 90 billable members x $0.13About $11.70
Zendra MembershipsGrowth: $9 + $10 band for 76 to 150 members$19

1. Appstle Memberships

Appstle Memberships by Appstle Memberships is a Built for Shopify app that lets you sell Amazon Prime-style memberships from your own store. You create plans, attach perks like member pricing, shipping benefits, or gated access, and the app bills members at the interval you choose. Smart tagging links each customer to the right perks, so discounts apply without manual work.

Appstle Memberships

The app solves a common pain: running memberships across spreadsheets, tags, and separate billing tools. Here, plans, perks, and billing live in one place inside Shopify. A member portal lets customers manage their own plans, which cuts support emails. Higher plans add dunning to retry failed payments, cancellation flows, and custom email HTML for brands that want full control.

Key Features

  • Hands-on support that often replies within minutes and stays until the issue is solved.
  • Quick setup, with some merchants launching a full program in about two days.
  • Automatic checkout discounts for tiered members, such as monthly and quarterly plans.
  • Customer tag automation that ties subscription tags to the right member perks.
  • Protected pages and members-only areas, including large digital document libraries.
  • Exclusive VIP catalogs and collection access for top-tier members.
  • Smooth data transfer when moving existing members from another provider.

Ratings and Reviews: Appstle Memberships holds a 5.0 out of 5 rating from 952+ reviews on the Shopify App Store.

Pricing

  • Free: $0, up to 25 memberships.
  • Starter: $19/month or $182.40/year, up to 100 memberships, 14-day free trial.
  • Business: $39/month or $374.40/year, up to 500 memberships, 14-day free trial.
  • Business Premium: $79/month or $758.40/year, up to 750 memberships, 14-day free trial.

Best for: Brands that want predictable flat pricing and guided help launching their first paid membership.

Use it wisely: Plans are capped by membership count, so estimate your 6-month member numbers before picking a tier. Turn on dunning before your first renewal cycle.

2. Simplee Memberships & Loyalty

Simplee Memberships & Loyalty by Simplee Memberships & Loyalty is a Built for Shopify app for paid loyalty programs, similar to Costco or Amazon Prime. Members get product and shipping discounts, including on their very first order, online or at Shopify POS. The app can also give store credit back on membership orders, which gives members a reason to return.

Simplee Memberships & Loyalty

It suits merchants who want memberships that feel native to Shopify. Memberships run as regular Shopify products and orders, so your data stays in one place. You can paywall pages, products, collections, or blogs. Free trials, discounted trials, setup fees, and one-time memberships give you room to test offers. Klaviyo, Omnisend, and Flow keep member emails and automations on track.

Key Features

  • Quick, friendly support, including help on weekend evenings.
  • Custom code built for unique needs, sometimes running within hours.
  • Memberships run on Shopify’s own products, orders, and payment gateway.
  • Restricts content and discounted products to members only.
  • Pairs membership plans with digital downloads.
  • Pricing merchants describe as very reasonable for what it offers.
  • Long-term reliability, with one studio running its program for over four years.

Ratings and Reviews: Simplee Memberships & Loyalty holds a 4.9 out of 5 rating from 79+ reviews on the Shopify App Store.

Pricing

  • Developer Store: Free for any development store.
  • Growth: $9.75/month plus a monthly fee of $0.05 to $0.30 per active member, which decreases as the program grows. 14-day free trial.

Best for: Stores that sell online and in person, such as studios, cafés, and retail shops that want member pricing at the counter.

Use it wisely: The per-member fee scales with your program, so model costs at your expected size. Use a first-order discount so joining feels worth it right away.

3. Conjured Memberships

Conjured Memberships by Conjured is a membership program tool that creates recurring revenue even when your products do not suit a subscription. You can offer free shipping, member discounts, early access to new releases, and gated content such as classes and downloads. A fully integrated portal keeps the member area on brand and inside your Shopify theme.

Conjured Memberships

The app targets a real headache: gluing memberships together with several apps and custom code. Conjured handles members, perks, and gated access in one place and works with native checkout. Starter and higher plans include unlimited members, fully customizable HTML and emails, and members-only pricing. It connects with Klaviyo, Mailchimp, SendGrid, and Churnbuster for messaging and payment recovery.

Key Features

  • Fast, responsive support, even outside business hours.
  • Product locking across multiple tiers and price plans.
  • Sells paywalled digital downloads, physical products, and blog-post guides together.
  • A member area that feels like a website within your website.
  • Replaces a patchwork of apps and custom code with one automated setup.
  • Design changes to the membership page, sometimes delivered within hours.
  • Changelog: Long-term users note regular updates and new features over time.

Ratings and Reviews: Conjured Memberships holds a 4.9 out of 5 rating from 84+ reviews on the Shopify App Store.

Pricing

  • Free (Development): $0 for Shopify Partner and Shopify Plus development stores.
  • Limited Special: $9.99/month plus 2.9% of membership transactions (min $0.10). 30-day free trial.
  • Starter: $19/month plus 1.9% of membership transactions (min $0.10). 30-day free trial.
  • Growth: $69/month plus 0.9% of membership transactions (min $0.10). 30-day free trial.

Best for: Creators and brands selling classes, guides, or downloads alongside physical products.

Use it wisely: Transaction fees step down on higher plans, so compare each plan against your monthly membership revenue. Decide on annual or monthly renewals before launch.

4. Bold Memberships & Loyalty

Bold Memberships & Loyalty by Bold combines free loyalty tiers and paid membership tiers in one program. Member pricing, store credit, free shipping, early access, and member-only products apply automatically. You can lock products, pages, or checkout behind scheduled early access, which works well for product drops and limited releases.

Bold Memberships & Loyalty

The app fits merchants who sell both online and in physical stores. Members can carry a card in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet and use it at Shopify POS. A redemption catalog, birthday gifts, and expiring store credit add depth to the loyalty side. Brands with several stores can run one membership across every brand, and the app supports seven languages.

Key Features

  • Live chat support described as fast, knowledgeable, and pleasant.
  • Reliable handling of VIP memberships and restricted access.
  • Recurring payments that do the job merchants need.
  • Works well with Shopify, Stripe, and custom themes.
  • Merchants report six-figure membership revenue since 2020.
  • Pricing seen as fair for the engagement and management it provides.
  • Helpful workaround tips, such as tag-based member-only discount codes.

Ratings and Reviews: Bold Memberships & Loyalty holds a 4.4 out of 5 rating from 89+ reviews on the Shopify App Store.

Pricing

  • Scale: Free to install; $0.13 per member, per month.
  • First 10 members free forever, no flat monthly base fee, no transaction fees.
  • 100% free for the first 30 days.

Best for: Omnichannel and multi-brand retailers who want one program across POS and online.

Use it wisely: With per-member pricing, cost tracks growth, so review member counts monthly. Use expiring store credit to prompt a return visit, not as a permanent discount.

5. Zendra Memberships

Zendra Memberships by Kestrel is a Built for Shopify app that sells memberships with subscription billing, self-service accounts, and member-only perks. You can sell product subscriptions, subscribe-and-save offers, and lifetime or recurring memberships right from product pages. Custom billing intervals, trials, sign-up fees, and billing-cycle limits help you shape each plan.

Zendra Memberships

The app tackles a quiet revenue leak: failed renewals. Automatic retries and lifecycle emails help recover payments before members drop off. Members update payment methods or cancel inside their Shopify accounts, which reduces support tickets. You can drip or schedule access to content, assign Discord roles, and track churn risk in reports. The app supports 36 languages.

Key Features

  • Support that takes time to understand your goals instead of sending canned replies.
  • A first membership plan set up in about 10 minutes.
  • Handles complex programs with protected content, member dashboards, and custom pages.
  • Clean, reliable, and well integrated with Shopify.
  • A free plan that works for free memberships to capture leads.
  • Membership plans that look polished when shown to customers.
  • Help available in many languages, with personal follow-up.

Ratings and Reviews: Zendra Memberships holds a 5.0 out of 5 rating from 15+ reviews on the Shopify App Store.

Pricing

  • Free: $0, up to 75 members, unlimited tiers, plans, and perks.
  • Growth: $9/month plus usage charges, up to 10,000 members. 10-day free trial.
  • Growth usage per month: first 75 members free; 76 to 150 = $10; 151 to 500 = $30; 501 to 1,000 = $70; 1,001 to 5,000 = $190; 5,001+ = $340.

Best for: New stores, creators, and community brands that want to start free and grow, especially with Discord.

Use it wisely: Usage bands step up at set member counts, so time promotions with them in mind. Start with a free membership to build a list, then add a paid tier.

What Is a Shopify Membership App?

A Shopify membership app lets customers pay a recurring or one-time fee for ongoing perks. Perks can include member pricing, free shipping, store credit, early access, or gated content. The app bills members, tags them, and applies perks at checkout automatically.

Why Memberships Change How Customers Shop

Once people pay for something, they want their money’s worth. A member who paid $10 this month feels a small pull to use that free shipping. That pull brings them back to your store before they browse elsewhere. A one-time coupon creates no pull, because nothing was invested.

Belonging matters too. Gated pages and early drops tell members they are on the inside. That is why paid programs are now normal: 63% of consumers already belong to at least one paid loyalty program.

Where Memberships Fit in Your Store

  • Product pages: Show the member price beside the regular price.
  • Cart: Show how much this order would save as a member.
  • Shopify POS: Let in-store shoppers join and use perks at the counter.
  • Email: Send a monthly savings summary so members see their value.

When to Launch a Membership Program

Launch when customers already buy from you more than once. Consumables, coffee, pet supplies, beauty, and hobby products fit well, as do brands selling classes or guides. Time the launch a few weeks before a product drop, and invite top repeat buyers first.

Conclusion

Winning a first order is expensive, and watching that customer disappear hurts. A membership program gives shoppers a reason to return, because they have already invested in the relationship. The right Shopify membership app handles billing, perks, and access for you.

Match the app’s pricing model to your expected member count. Keep perks simple and easy to calculate, protect renewals with payment retries, and keep cancellation fair. Start with your best customers and grow from there.

FAQs

What is the best Shopify membership app for a small store?

Start with an app that offers a free plan or free member allowance. Test with a small group, then upgrade once renewals hold steady.

Can I sell memberships at Shopify POS?

Yes, several apps support member perks at Shopify POS. Some also offer wallet member cards for in-store use.

How much should I charge for a membership?

Price it so a regular customer earns back the fee within one or two orders. Test with your best buyers first.

Can I gate content like blogs, pages, or downloads?

Yes. Most Shopify membership apps can restrict pages, blogs, products, or collections to members.

What happens when a member’s payment fails?

Many apps retry failed payments and send reminder emails, often called dunning. Turn it on before your first renewal.

Dipen

Shopify Expert

Dipen Panchal, Shopify Tech Lead at Setubridge Technolabs, brings over a decade of expertise as a Shopify Expert. Passionate about e-commerce growth, he specializes in UI/UX design, crafting intuitive, engaging solutions tailored for merchants and B2B clients to enhance user experiences.

Related Blogs
Top 5 Shopify Membership Apps

Picture two shoppers on your Shopify store. Both love your coffee beans. One buys a bag ...

Top Shopify UGC & Instagram Feed Apps

A shopper lands on your store from an ad. She likes the dress, but she has ...

Shopify Customization Studio

It is 11 p.m., and a shopper is looking at your product page. She likes the ...